Wednesday, September 1, 2010

Well, I've read three fifths of Doctor Zhivago, and it seems a shame not to finish it, although it's like running uphill. My hat's off to anyone who has suffered through the whole thing. Hundreds of characters that seem like thousands, with unpronounceable names; there may really be only a few dozens, their names change so often that you can't be sure whom you've met before. The very length of the names makes them exhausting to read. Yuri and Tonia are almost always referred to as Yurii Andreievich and Antonina Alexandrovna. And those are two of the easiest.

The first half of the book takes place during "the war" that's going on before the Russian revolution, and you don't know which war or who "the enemy" is until deep into the quagmire.

This is one instance where the movie is definitely better than the book. In fact, it's one of my favorite movies. Or used to be. I don't know if I'd ever watch it again, except for the exquisite landscape scenery, and the great and beautiful actors in it--Omar Sharif, Julie Christie, Geraldine Chaplin. Even old Rod Steiger was great; corrupt and nasty as Komarovsky was, he had a good heart, and I felt sorry for him every time he got his come-uppance. And even in the book, he was always Victor Ippolitovitch Komarovsky--only eleven syllables.

5 comments:

JD Atlanta said...

"Hundreds of characters that seem like thousands, with unpronounceable names; there may really be only a few dozens, their names change so often that you can't be sure whom you've met before. "

That's why it took me 3 tries to get all the way through The Lord of the Rings.

I like Rod Steiger - at least, the movies I've seen that he was in.

Ramey Channell said...

"Hundreds of characters that seem like thousands, there may really be only a few dozens; their names change so often that you can't be sure whom you've met before. "

Felt the same way about Watership Down. After about one third of the book, I thought the author was probably awfully proud of thinking up all those cute names. I couldn't keep the characters attached to the names at all.

Maybe writers should limit their books to less than 100 characters, and keep the names simple.

JD Atlanta said...

Hey, you gave this 4 stars?? It must have gotten better in the last 2/5ths!

Joanne Cage said...

Mainly because of the last section, "The Conclusion." It was beyond words marvelous, and you realized there were spots like that throughout the book. It's a hard read, but worth it to me--in retrospect.

The movie is misleading about Strelnikov (Pasha Antipov). He turned out to be as superior as Lara said he was.

Joanne Cage said...

That's one great thing about this book: Zhivago and Lara TOTALLY KNEW everyone they were acquainted with. Their minds worked identically, even more so than Zhivago ever realized. When he finally met Strelnikov at the end, he seemed to agree with Lara's analysis.

One of the most moving parts of the book was Tonia's last letter to her husband Zhivago: "The thing is, I love you and you don't love me." He did, but Lara was his soul-mate.